NewsMontana News


A Wilder View: The surprising truth about ‘Alpha’ wolves

This edition of A Wilder View separates myth from reality and uncovers the surprising truth about wolves having "Alphas."
Posted at 8:33 AM, Sep 21, 2023
and last updated 2023-09-21 10:33:08-04

This edition of A Wilder View separates myth from reality and uncovers the surprising truth about wolves having "Alphas."

Wolf packs have fascinated scientists, wildlife enthusiasts, and even pop culture for centuries but, it's time to separate fact from fiction surrounding the captivating concept of alpha wolves.

For decades, researchers believed in the existence of an Alpha wolf within a pack — a dominant, aggressive leader who ruled with an iron paw. Movies like 'The Grey' and countless documentaries further amplified this notion of an unyielding pack leader. Yet, biologists have now turned this narrative on its head.

The concept of Alpha wolves was first started by a 1948 publication by Rudolph Schenkel. In his research he explains the dynamics within wolf packs, wherein an alpha pair engages in a fierce battle for dominance, ultimately securing exclusive mating privileges within the group.

Dave Mech, a wolf researcher with the U.S Geological Survey, is who actually popularized the idea in a book published in 1970 entitled “The Wolf: Ecology and Behavior of an Endangered Species.”

The problem is that this research was in captive environments so, it doesn't reflect the reality of wild wolf pack dynamics. It’s something Mech pointed out in a later publication in 1999.

In the wild, wolf packs are typically family units, consisting of parents and their offspring. These packs don't have a linear hierarchy with an alpha male and an Alpha female. Instead, they work together as a cohesive unit to survive and raise their young.

Over the years, our understanding of wolf behavior has evolved. Mech himself has revised his views and renounced the concept of Alpha wolves, stating that he wishes he could take it all back. He even has gone as far as trying to stop publishers from printing his book.

While the Alpha wolf concept doesn't hold in the wolf world, it remains a valid theory in other contexts. In some primates, like silverback gorillas, Alpha males indeed exist where the male’s ranks determine their reproductive success; gaining the responsibility to protect others.

So, why does it matter that we debunk the myth of Alpha wolves? Well, these misconceptions have influenced not only how we view wolves but also how we view leadership and social structures in our own world.

The idea of an Alpha wolf has been used to justify hierarchical models of leadership, which can perpetuate harmful power dynamics in human society. This shows how science is ever-evolving and on a constant quest for knowledge.

Personally, I have always liked the term practicing medicine in the medical field -- showing that we are always finding out more and accepting when we are right and more importantly when we are wrong.